This guide highlights a selection of leading products and services. When you buy through our links, we may be compensated.

Banner background

Mobile banner background

Home Warranty Comparisons: Which One Is Best? February 2026

Protect your biggest investment from unexpected repairs. Here's our expert home warranty comparison for coverage, value, and customer service.

Updated February 16, 2026

Our Recommendations

1

Consumer's Best

8.7

Excellent

Higher coverage caps on key items.

Premium coverage, generous limits.
Includes coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions.
Offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.

2

Choice Home Warranty

8.3

Very Good

Straightforward plans, broad availability.

Easy-to-understand coverage.
Nationwide service professionals.
Dedicated customer service line.

3

7.5

Good

Highly customizable, many add-ons.

Huge list of optional add-on coverage.
A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
Tailor a plan to your specific needs.

4

HSC Home Warranty

7

Good

Long-standing history, combo plans.

In business for over 45 years.
Offers discounts for multi-year plans.
ShieldEssential plan is very affordable.

5

US Home Guard

6.9

Fair

Simple plans, clear pricing.

Two straightforward plan choices.
Covers duplex, triplex, and fourplex homes.
Provides 24/7 online claims service.

Compare Our Top 2 Picks

Here’s a direct comparison to show you how our ‘Consumer's Best’ choice stacks up against the competition.

Features
	8.7	8.3
Plan Options	Gold Plan, Platinum Plan	Basic Plan, Total Plan
Service Call Fee	$75 - $100	$85 - $100
Coverage Highlights	High coverage caps, Green-Plus eco-friendly replacement option	Simple, comprehensive coverage for major systems & appliances
State Availability	48 States	49 States
Workmanship Guarantee	30 days	60 days (parts), 90 days (labor)

Our Top Pick

1

Consumer's Best

8.7

Excellent

Premium coverage, generous limits.
Includes coverage for unknown pre-existing conditions.
Offers a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Featured Topics

Home Security Systems

Best Home Security & Smart Locks

Find the best home security systems and smart locks of 2025. Consumers Best reviews Vivint, Lockly, and more for safety and convenience.

Term Life Insurance

Best Term Life Insurance Companies of 2025

Find the best term life insurance policy. Our 2025 review compares Ethos, SelectQuote & more for affordable rates, no-exam options, and coverage.

Balance Transfer Cards

Best Balance Transfer Credit Cards of 2026

Find the best balance transfer card to pay down debt. Our 2025 review compares top 0% intro APR offers, fees, and rewards to help you save money.

High-Yield Savings Accounts

Best High-Yield Savings Accounts of 2026

Find the best high-yield savings account. Our 2025 review compares Ally, Varo, and more for high APY rates, no monthly fees, and FDIC insurance.